• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Painting Perceptions

  • Home
  • Workshops
  • Advertise
  • About
    • About Painting Perceptions
    • Contact Us
    • Links
  • Articles
    • Posts Archive List
    • Great Reads
    • Sounding Technical
    • Art Politics
    • Art Books
  • Interviews
    • Featured Interviews
    • A Question or Two
    • notable painters

Has Conceptual Art Jumped the Shark Tank?

October 16, 2009 By Larry 10 Comments

Great Op-Ed article in today’s New York Times called:
Has Conceptual Art Jumped the Shark Tank? by Denis Dutton.

I don’t want to jump out of my own tank too soon but reading this article makes me wonder if there might still be hope the art world could again embrace beauty as a valid pursuit?

Filed Under: Art Politics

Donate to Painting Perceptions


Donations to Painting Perceptions helps this site greatly, please consider your gift today.

Previous Post: « Bonnard's Late Interiors – Met Curator Talk
Next Post: Interview with George Nick – Part One, On Edwin Dickinson »

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Philip Koch

    October 17, 2009 at 1:28 pm

    Good essay. The collector market for conceptual art is like an aging hot air ballon- its just a matter of time before its seams start to leak and it comes, either drifting or crashing down, to earth. (Of course I’ve been saying the same thing about Warhol’s Brillo boxes for the last 40 years and they’ve had way more staying power than I would ever have thought possible back in 1969, so what do I know). Wish the NY Times could have run a photo of a few of the prehistoric hand axes Prof. Dutton describes.

    Reply
    • Larry

      October 17, 2009 at 7:42 pm

      Philip said:

      The collector market for conceptual art is like an aging hot air ballon- its just a matter of time before its seams start to leak and it comes, either drifting or crashing down, to earth.

      Let’s hope there aren’t too many little boys on board when it does!
      I have a hard time feeling empathetic with the last collector who is stuck holding onto something like the Hirst’s medicine cabinet. There should be consequences for
      stupidity.

      Reply
  2. Valentino

    October 17, 2009 at 6:54 pm

    >Wish the NY Times could have run a photo of a few of the prehistoric hand axes Prof. Dutton describes.

    Some examples can be see here:
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acheulean

    Reply
    • Larry

      October 17, 2009 at 7:31 pm

      Thanks Valentino!
      Good to see this stuff. With the grim predictions for the environment, these axes might again be handy!

      Reply
  3. Valentino

    October 18, 2009 at 4:27 pm

    >There should be consequences for
    stupidity.

    Definitely.
    The last collector more than deserve his share of those.

    Reply
  4. Valentino

    October 18, 2009 at 4:37 pm

    Btw, it took more than 20 years for critics in Britain to come to their sense:
    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/art/6329047/It-couldnt-get-worse-for-Damien-Hirst.html
    I wonder how long the American art establishment will need to become serious about art.

    Reply
    • Larry

      October 20, 2009 at 3:58 am

      Valentino said,

      Btw, it took more than 20 years for critics in Britain to come to their sense:
      http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/art/6329047/It-couldnt-get-worse-for-Damien-Hirst.html

      Valentino, Great link to the article about Damien Hirst! I hadn’t seen that before. His paintings are really awful but what is more dreadful is their being hung next to a Poussin – how that could happen is beyond comprehension.

      Reply
  5. TDK

    October 18, 2009 at 6:15 pm

    People are no longer fooled by the large inkjet printer and their images painted over with oil paint anymore, thus creating the dead image.

    I guess that’s why the likes of a Peter Doig are getting 500,000 per now. Things are looking good for the art world. The realists are finally dying thanks to a digital world and the creative imaginable works are coming on strong. I guess it just takes time for the minds like a Cézanne or Bonnard to finally take hold.

    Reply
  6. Valentino

    October 20, 2009 at 6:47 pm

    Yes, it is a refreshingly sane view on idiocy called conceptual “art”. I haven’t read too many articles like this in mainstream press. Maybe one or two.

    I receive Wallace newsletter several times a year. When I learned about this exhibition several weeks ago, I was little suspicious. Who has chosen the venue for that show? If it was someone of the Wallace staff they must have had a secret agenda – to show that the emperor is completely naked.

    If it was someone else, perhaps he got tired of BS. I can not imagine a gallery that could be less suitable for the Hirst show. The contrast simply could not have been more stark. Those who hasn’t visited Wallace can only try to imagine the size of unfathomable gap between the sublime works in their collection and that Hirst garbage.
    He must be really stupid to publicly expose his nakedness (that is – a complete inadequacy in making art) this way.
    It is as though somebody lacking ability to sing in pitch insisted to join Metropolitan Opera Choir.

    Reply
  7. Alex

    October 23, 2009 at 10:35 pm

    Hirst and his ilk are simply showing the “art world” to be what it is and has long been- a bunch of pompous, self-indulgent, self-referential arseholes who are easily suckered. As much as I find Hirst to be a (bad)joke, it’s the people who gave him credibility in the “art world” who should come under the real criticism…

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Donate to Painting Perceptions


Donations to Painting Perceptions helps this site greatly, please consider your gift today.

Subscribe

Subscribe to the Painting Perceptions Mailing List

* indicates required

ADS

A unique opportunity to work at the prestigious Ballinglen Arts Foundation. for a select group of nine artists to spend nine days in rural Ireland drawing and painting.

Click for more information and registration»

Painting in Tuscany, Italy 2025 with Dean Fisher

September 8- 16, 2025 and September 16- 23, 2025

Dean Fisher Italy Workshop Click for details and registration»

Popular Reads

INTERVIEWS:
Lennart Anderson
Gerry Bergstein
Robert Birmelin
Lois Dodd
Stanley Lewis (two parts)
A Frank Galuszka
Dan Gustin
Vincent Desiderio
Susannah Phillips
Ann Gale
Elizabeth Higgins
Diana Horowitz
Duane Keiser
Susan Jane Walp
Grant Drumheller
Caren Canier
Jane Culp
Lani Irwin
Alan Feltus
Langdon Quin
Julian Kreimer
Israel Hershberg
Yael Scalia
Michael Tompkins
Sigal Tsabari
Gillian Pederson-Krag
Stuart Shils
Harold Reddicliffe
Robert Dukes
Eric Aho
Kyle Staver
Alex Kanevsky
John Dubrow
ARTICLES AND REVIEWS
Memories of Philip Guston
Auden and Faulkner in the Work of Stanley Lewis
Ken Kewley, Writings on Color
Walter Tandy Murch
Gretna Campbell
Louis Finkelstien, On Painterly
VIDEO REVIEWS, MISC
“The Art of Gregory Gillespie: In Conversation, Simon Dinnerstein and Peggy Gillespie”
“Patrick George – A Likeness”
Morandi’s Dust
Lennart Anderson Slide Talk

Landscapes

  • Slayer of Windmills meets the Devil at the Crossroads
  • Review of Our Kids Play Together: A Show of Paintings by Elise Schweitzer and Laura Vahlberg
  • STANLEY LEWIS – TRADITION AND THE INDIVIDUAL TALENT
  • Interview with Cathy Diamond
  • Interview with Kathleen Dunn Jacobs

Still Life Painters

  • Review of “CONVERSATIONS: 23 Interviews with Still Life Artists” by Zeuxis
  • Interview with Marie Riccio
  • Interview with Paula Heisen
  • Interview with John Lee
  • Elizabeth Geiger’s, Borrowed Rhythms, at the Gross McCleaf

Figure Painters

  • Interview with Barbara Grossman
  • Interview with Bruce Lieberman
  • Interview with Tony Serio
  • A Conversation With Philip Geiger
  • Visible Influence: Janet Niewald and Wilbur Niewald

Footer

More Selections from the Archive

Interview with Susannah Phillips

Susannah Phillips was raised in London and attended the Slade School of Fine Art in London. Her paintings have been in many solo and group exhibitions in London, New York and Provincetown, MA, and are included in numerous private collections. In 2014 and 2017, she was awarded the Josef and Anni Albers Foundation Residency. The artist lives and ...

Read More

Conversation with Lois Dodd

Lois Dodd has been painting her everyday surroundings for sixty years. Her current exhibition, from February 26 through April 4, 2015 at the Alexandre Gallery in NYC shows twenty-four recent small-scaled paintings that depict familiar motifs such as gardens, houses, interiors and views from windows. Dodd, now eighty-seven, is an iconic figure of ...

Read More

Interview with Ann Gale

by Larry Groff I am honored that Ann Gale agreed to this telephone interview and thank her greatly for being so generous with her time and attention with sharing thoughts about her art and process. Ann Gale is a leading American figurative painter living in Seattle. Her portraits were shown alongside other leading painters of the figure ...

Read More

See More;

Painting Perceptions was started in 2009 by Larry Groff to promote the ideas, practice and experience of painters working from observation in a modernist vein from around the world through interviews, essays, videos and community. It later evolved to include imagination-based and abstract painting as well.More Info →

Copyright © 2025 Painting Perceptions on the Foodie Pro Theme